Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear vs Milwaukee M12 Shear - EngiMarket

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear vs Milwaukee M12 Shear

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

If you’re in the market for a reliable cutting tool, you may have come across two popular options from Milwaukee: the M12 PVC Shear and the M12 Shear. Both tools offer efficient cutting solutions, but it’s essential to understand their differences to make an informed decision. Let’s explore the features and capabilities of each to help you choose the best tool for your specific needs.

Precise Cutting

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear
Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
9.3

The Milwaukee M12 12-Volt Cordless PVC Shear is a powerful tool with a patented shear mechanism that can cut up to 2-inch Schedule 80 PVC quickly and efficiently. With a razor-sharp pierce point and stainless steel blade, this impact and water-resistant tool is perfect for a variety of materials. Please note that this product is a power tool only; batteries, chargers, and accessories are sold separately.

Metal Cutting

Milwaukee M12 Shear
Milwaukee M12 Shear
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
9.1

The Milwaukee Electric Tool 2470-21 M12 Cordless Shear Kit is a powerful and versatile tool that includes a pipe shear, battery, charger, and carrying case. With its ultra sharp blade, impact, water, and rust-resistant design, and ability to cut up to 2″ schedule 40 PVC in just 3 seconds, this 12 V Li-Ion cordless shear kit is a reliable and efficient solution for your cutting needs.

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear

Weight
4.71 pounds

Battery
No battery included

Voltage
12 Volts

Package Contents
Tool only, no battery or charger

Product Dimensions
N/A

Milwaukee M12 Shear

Weight
10 pounds

Battery
Includes 1 Lithium Ion battery

Voltage
120 Volts

Package Contents
Includes battery, charger, and carrying case

Product Dimensions
18.3 x 6.3 x 14.6 inches

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear

Advantages
  • Leaves a clean edge with no burs
  • Great for quick cuts on ABS and some PVC pipes
  • Increases job performance and speed by at least 50%

Milwaukee M12 Shear

Advantages
  • Makes clean, straight cuts quickly, saving time and effort
  • Easy to use and reduces strain on hands compared to manual cutters
  • Versatile tool that can cut various materials like PVC, coaxial cable, tree branches, etc

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear

Cons
  • It’s heavier than it seems, not ideal for tight quarters cutting
  • Cutting head is large for up to 2-inch diameter pipes, limiting use in some situations

Milwaukee M12 Shear

Cons
  • Compact M12 battery pack arrived totally discharged and indicated as defective by the charger in one review
  • Difficult controls, particularly the trigger unlock button, mentioned in another review

Comparison

Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear vs Milwaukee M12 Shear
Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear
VS
Milwaukee M12 Shear
Power Source
Cordless – Battery not included
VS
Cordless – Includes Li-Ion battery
Included in Kit
Power Tool Only
VS
Power Tool + Li-Ion battery + Charger
Maximum Cutting Capacity
Up to 2-3/8″ PVC
VS
Up to 2-3/8″ PVC
Weight
Lightweight
VS
Lightweight
Blade Design
Quick, clean cuts with burr-free edges
VS
Quick, clean cuts with burr-free edges
Speed
High RPM for efficient cutting
VS
High RPM for efficient cutting
Ergonomics
Comfortable grip and easy maneuverability
VS
Comfortable grip and easy maneuverability

Milwaukee M12 2470-20:

  • USPs: Power tool only – flexibility to choose compatible accessories, lightweight, quick clean cuts.
  • Pros: Freedom to select battery and charger, easy to handle.
  • Cons: Additional cost for battery and charger, not a complete kit.
  • Use-cases: Ideal for those who already have M12 batteries and chargers, professionals needing a lightweight PVC shear.

Milwaukee M12 2470-21:

  • USPs: Complete kit with battery and charger included, similar cutting capacity and features.
  • Pros: Ready-to-use kit, lightweight and ergonomic design.
  • Cons: Higher initial investment, potentially less flexibility in battery choice.
  • Use-cases: Great for beginners or those looking for a hassle-free, ready-to-use solution, DIY enthusiasts.

Conclusive Assessment:

If you prioritize convenience and want a complete package, the Milwaukee M12 2470-21 kit is the clear winner. However, if you already own M12 batteries and chargers or prefer a more tailored setup, the Milwaukee M12 2470-20 gives you more flexibility and cost-saving options.

Final Summary:

In summary, for those seeking a comprehensive solution with all accessories included, the Milwaukee M12 2470-21 kit is the top choice. On the other hand, if customization and budget flexibility are essential, opt for the Milwaukee M12 2470-20 for a tailored power tool experience.

Comparing PVC Pipe Cutters: Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear vs. Milwaukee M12 Shear

When it comes to choosing between PVC pipe cutters like the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear and the Milwaukee M12 Shear, there are several key factors you need to consider to make an informed decision. Here are some guidelines and factors to help you compare the two products effectively:

1. Functionality and Features

  • The Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear is specifically designed for cutting PVC pipes, while the Milwaukee M12 Shear is a more versatile tool for cutting various materials.
  • Consider the cutting capacity and blade size of each cutter to ensure it meets your project requirements.

2. Power Source and Portability

  • Both products are part of Milwaukee’s M12 line, which means they are powered by M12 batteries for cordless operation.
  • Evaluate the weight and dimensions of each cutter for ease of handling and transportation.

3. Durability and Build Quality

  • Look into the construction materials and overall durability of the PVC Shear and Shear to assess their longevity under different working conditions.

4. User Experience and Ergonomics

  • Check for ergonomic features such as grip design, safety mechanisms, and ease of use that can impact the user experience.
  • Consider any additional accessories or functionalities that come with each product, like LED lights for better visibility.

5. Price and Value Proposition

  • Compare the pricing of both PVC pipe cutters against their features, capabilities, and brand reputation to determine the best value for your investment.

Remember, the best choice between the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear and the Milwaukee M12 Shear depends on your specific needs and preferences. Take time to assess these factors before making a purchase to ensure you get the right tool for your projects.

PVC Pipe Cutter Milwaukee FAQs

Is the Milwaukee M12 Shear compatible with the same blades as the PVC Shear?

The Milwaukee M12 Shear and the Milwaukee M12 Cordless PVC Shear are different tools, and they may not be compatible with the same blades. It’s essential to use blades specifically designed for your tool to ensure proper function and safety. Make sure to check the manufacturer’s guidelines or contact Milwaukee for accurate information on blade compatibility for each model.

Are there any notable performance variations between the two Milwaukee shears?

Both Milwaukee shears provide high-quality performance, but there are some notable differences between the two models. The Milwaukee M12 12-Volt Cordless PVC Shear (2470-20) is sold as a power tool only, meaning you would need to purchase the battery, charger, and accessories separately. On the other hand, the Milwaukee Electric Tool 2470-21 M12 Cordless Shear Kit comes as a kit, including a 12V Li-Ion battery and charger.

In terms of performance, the kit version (2470-21) offers a more convenient and ready-to-use option since it includes the necessary battery and charger. The power tool only version (2470-20) allows for more flexibility in terms of choosing your battery and charger setup.

Overall, the choice between the two Milwaukee shears may come down to your preference for convenience and customization. Both models are reliable and efficient tools for cutting PVC and other materials.

Which materials are suitable for cutting with the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear?

The Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear is specifically designed for cutting PVC material. It is not recommended for cutting other types of materials like metal, wood, or other plastics. For optimal performance and long tool life, it is best to use this tool only for cutting PVC pipes and tubes.

What are the key differences between the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear and the Milwaukee M12 Shear?

The key differences between the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear (2470-20) and the Milwaukee M12 Shear (2470-21) are:

  1. Purpose:
    • The Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear (2470-20) is specifically designed for cutting PVC pipe.
    • The Milwaukee M12 Shear (2470-21) is a more general shear that can be used for cutting various materials like metal, fabric, plastics, and more.
  2. Kit Inclusions:
    • The Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear (2470-20) is sold as a power tool only, meaning it does not come with a battery, charger, or accessories.
    • The Milwaukee M12 Shear (2470-21) is a kit that includes the shear, a 12-volt Lithium-Ion battery, a charger, and possibly other accessories depending on the kit.
  3. Application:
    • The Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear (2470-20) has a specialized design for clean cuts on PVC pipes, making it ideal for plumbing and electrical work.
    • The Milwaukee M12 Shear (2470-21) is more versatile and can be used in a wider range of applications due to its ability to cut different materials.

These distinctions could help you choose the most suitable shear based on your specific needs and projects.

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

3 Comments
Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
  1. I’d love to know more about the pricing of both the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear and the Milwaukee M12 Shear. Understanding the value proposition would help in making a decision.

    • Pricing and value are definitely important factors to consider when choosing between tools. I’ll provide a breakdown of the costs and benefits in a separate comparison post.

  2. I’ve been using the Milwaukee M12 PVC Shear for a while now, and it’s been a game-changer for my projects. The precision and ease of use make cutting PVC pipes a breeze.

Leave a reply

EngiMarket
Logo
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
Ninja Silhouette 9 hours ago

Joe Doe in London, England purchased a

Joe Doe in London?

Joe Doe in London, England purchased a

Joe Doe in London?

Joe Doe in London, England purchased a

Joe Doe in London?

Joe Doe in London, England purchased a